Studies on pediatric Cannabis are rolling in and I want to put a handful on your radar and show you where you can find the rest. I’ll try to spare you my analysis because I want you to come to your own conclusions. I don’t believe in one size fits all. Some of us in our community may share the same diagnosis, but we don’t share the same circumstances. You live in a different state, have different resources, have a different understanding of life than I do. Your child is different than mine. Not every supplement or pharmaceutical effects everyone the same way. (Except vaccinations. They are completely safe for every single person on the planet. Insert eye roll.) Unlike setting a broken arm, treating epilepsy or autism or a wide range of neurological condition calls for very individualized treatment.
This requires parents to be very informed and involved in decision making. Maybe randomized controlled trials are where you find your next move. Maybe it’s in the story and eyes of another mother. You decide what feels risky or safe for your child in consideration of the options available that align with your values. I trust that only you can know what that is.
Dr. Margaret Gedde and Dr. Bonni Goldstein are the leading physicians in pediatric Cannabis. On the Realm of Caring’s website, you can find their retrospective cohort studies of epilepsy patients treated with Cannabis. No, they haven’t been published in a top medical journal, nor can they be found at the National Library of Medicine. This is what they saw in their day-to-day practice. So these results reflect different seizure disorders and the use of a variety of artisanal oils. For what it’s worth to you, below are their findings:
Dr. Gedde’s entire report can be found by clicking here and below is a brief summary:
- 107 patients, ages 6 months to 45 years (average age 9.9 years)
- 2/3 of patients used a high ratio CBD:THC oil
- 1/3 of patients used THC-A, a low ratio CBD:THC, or a combination
Summary of Seizure Reduction (within 16 weeks of starting treatment) | ||
Percent Seizure Reduction | Percent of Patients | Number of Patients |
At least 50% | 71% | 66/107 |
At least 80% | 43% | 36/107 |
100% | 11% | 12/107 |
Dr. Goldstein’s entire findings can be found by clicking here. Summary:
- 112 patients, ages 1 to 44 years
- all patients used a high ratio CBD:THC oil (15:1 - 31:1, one patient taking a 6:1)
Summary of Seizure Reduction | ||
Percent Seizure Reduction | Percent of Patients | Number of Patients |
No reduction | 10% | 11/112 |
No reduction but decrease in severity/duration |
16% | 18/112 |
25-49% | 9% | 10/112 |
50-74% | 16% | 18/112 |
75-99% | 38% | 42/112 |
100% | 12% | 13/112 |
If published research is more your style, you can review studies on Cannabis and epilepsy here at the National Library of Medicine. You can also click here to learn more about actually including your child in a Cannabis clinical trial.
The research on Epidiolex led by Dr. Oren Devinsky (you know, the one treating Harrison Ford’s daughter?) has been of high interest and they are rolling it out as it’s collected. These are not the results of controlled trials. Those are still in progress and supposedly coming this year.** You can find the abstract they presented at the 2015 Annual Meeting of the American Epilepsy Society here. Summary:
- 261 patients, ages 4 months to 41 years (average age 11.8 years)
- all patients taking Epidiolex (pharmaceutical grade CBD only)
- 47% had a greater than 50% reduction in seizures
- 9% were seizure free within 3 months
The University of Alabama has also been releasing the results of their Cannabidiol Program. They presented their results at the annual meeting of the American Academy of Neurology and you can read their press release here. Of the 51 patients included, 50% responded with seizures declining between 32% and 45%.
Hmmm . . . okay. So maybe a little bit of my own analysis because I was triggered recently. Disparaging Cannabis, a neurologist told me that everyone gets excited when a new seizure treatment comes out and thinks it’s going to be the next magic bullet. But that each time the 30% of epilepsy patients who are intractable remain largely unhelped.
Even though they aren’t controlled studies, I think the above actually flies directly in the face of his conclusions. This quote is from a piece of research that both he and I refer to often: “Drug-resistant epilepsy is defined as a failure of two or more appropriately selected and adequately tried anticonvulsant medications to achieve seizure freedom for a sustained period of time in either monotherapy or polytherapy. Once this definition has been met, the likelihood that further medication trials will lead to seizure freedom is in the range of 5% to 10%.” This 2011 study from the European Journal of Epilepsy acknowledges that there is “sparse” data “rationalizing” all those combinations of medications they are putting our children on.
I wonder how many of us would put a part in our car that had a 90% to 95% chance of not working and a strong possibility of making the problem worse.
In fairness, I do see some parents post on Facebook that their child is seizure free on polytherapy. I’ve never met one, but I know they are out there. I guess they are that lucky 5% to 10%. I froze after my son failed his 2nd medication and was too afraid to risk horrifying side effects. But I wasn’t seeing cognitive declines in the kids I met on Cannabis. I saw the opposite. In consideration of my personal values, Cannabis actually felt safer. I don’t know what I would have done if it wasn’t an option. I really don’t. As the days, months, years seized on, I might have ate my own words and rolled the dice.
Or accepted a palliative position instead, which would have been devastating. Absolutely heartbreaking. But so are damaging medications that decrease quality of life and don’t stop seizures.
For families in this position, the above demonstrates that Cannabis can give their children safe and comforting options for a higher quality of life. I have unending gratitude for everything everyone is doing to advance pediatric Cannabis in any way. There is so much hope.
* If you are in San Diego County and want to participate in an IRB approved study about parents treating their children with intractable epilepsy with Cannabis please e-mail anthropologist Dr. Elisa Sobo at [email protected]
** Doh! Two days after this post G.W. Pharma released the results of their first placebo trial. And guess what? It works, duh. You can click here to find their press release since I’m not up for writing another piece. I was also interviewed by the New York Times this morning about the same which you can find here.
Ray Mirzabegian says
Awesome information here. Good job my friend.
Allison Ray Benavides says
Love you with all my heart Ray! Thank you!
Nora Peña says
Thank you for sharing this information Allison. I think this gives parents like us who are new to this more hope for a better quality of life for our son.
Allison Ray Benavides says
I want that for your boy too mama. Thank you - you just made my night. Hugs xo
Donna Bond says
Thank you for the wonderful info, Allison! Quality of life is everything.
Allison Ray Benavides says
I agree. This disease really places you in the moment, doesn’t it? One day at a time for our babes. I’m interested in making each one the most comfortable. Love seeing you here Donna. Appreciate your support xo
Teresa reyes says
Vaccinations are not one size fits all ? I liked the article very much but that part is totally wrong ?i would repost the article to others but that part is totally false ? One size does not fit all unless you want a child with seizures , cancer later. Or hey maybe better yet death ? Autism on my child is what happened when I put toxins in her . Gods healing plant is what is healing my child and all natural is the only way to go ? One side of the fence or other . If you believe pharmas are the way to go ( not natural ) why cannabis ? After all injecting with poison defeats the purpose ?
Allison Ray Benavides says
I was being sarcastic and linked that statement to the Vaccination Injury Compensation Fund which acknowledges that injuries are true. It’s not about believing if they are safe (there is evidence that proves they aren’t for everyone), it’s about deciding which feels riskier - the disease they are trying to prevent or the vaccine itself. Thank you for pointing out that it didn’t come across! I edited that statement to hopefully clarify. I don’t want to send the wrong message. I agree with you mama. Thank you for reading and for your feedback. In this together xo
Sara Knowles says
Fantastic eye-opening article. I love reading your work. You are truly an amazing woman.. and I cannot wait to meet you and Rylie!!
Allison Ray Benavides says
YOU are the best Sara. I hope to meet you too.
Elizabeth Aquino says
Excellent article again, Allison! Your calm and reasoned yet heart-full approach to this complex issue is so admirable.
Allison Ray Benavides says
Ahhh . . . Once I get your stamp of approval I can relax xo
Margie Spitzmiller says
Thank you Allison for all your research and hard work and knowledge! I am stuck right now with Kristi and haven’t given her anything since Christmas. Cannot decide which way to turn. I am also bummed that I cannot make Friday’s meeting again!! Please let me know if you have time to chat. Maybe I need to call on M Sexton? Where should I go for information and guidance right now?
Allison Ray Benavides says
Yes Dr. Sexton can help with treatment planning. I’ll message you on Facebook.
Regina Gamboa says
Hi I recently posted on a private Special Needs Board on Facebook asking the question of parents that have tried High CBD oil for their children with seizures. Got some positive feedback. Was concerned about the cost. This is so hopeful! My daughter has been on every seizure med in the last 14 years except for carbonol, and I won’t go there. .she still has uncontrolled seizures weekly, but with each year,they ate becoming more violent..looking forward to the next step!
Allison Ray Benavides says
Regina I don’t know why anyone would discourage you. How rude! A lot has changed in the last 2 years to increase access and affordability. We can help you figure out how to do this sustainably. E-mail me at [email protected] We are here for you.